Reading Beyond The Errors

By -

 



This week, we worked in groups to analyze a Grade 3 child’s piece of writing. The experience was eye-opening because it reminded me that a child’s writing can show much more than what first meets the eye. The child wrote mostly in their first language and used very little punctuation. At first, it seemed full of errors, but as I looked closer, I began to notice a steady flow of ideas and real thought behind the words. Even though the piece did not follow all the conventions and mechanics, it showed a natural stream of thinking and a clear attempt to communicate meaning.


During our discussions, I realized how often teachers focus on correctness and forget to notice the ideas a child is trying to share. This exercise helped me see that the content and intention behind writing are just as important as grammar and punctuation. I also recognized that a child’s first language is not a barrier. It is a bridge that helps them organize their thoughts and express their experiences in ways that feel familiar.


What stood out most to me was the importance of encouraging self-expression first and teaching conventions gradually. Children need to feel that their ideas matter before they are ready to focus on technical accuracy. This activity reminded me that writing development takes time, guidance, and patience. It also strengthened my commitment to supporting young writers with understanding and care.

Comments

  1. Polly M. JeremiahOctober 27, 2025 at 3:28 AM

    Your sentiments really capture the veracity of our students language context, and how their first language influences their writing; not as an inadequate or error prone inferior piece of literature, but as one unique to the child's cultural language situation. It was great that you observed and pointed out, the need to not only focus on accuracy in relation to the target language, but expression, where the child has a message to ventilate.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Gloria WellsOctober 31, 2025 at 9:59 PM

    Your reflection really captured the heart of what it means to support young writers. I love how you recognized that a child’s first language is not a barrier but a bridge to deeper expression. Your point about valuing self-expression before focusing on conventions reminded me that true writing growth begins with confidence and meaning, not just correctness. Thank you for such an inspiring and thoughtful post. How do you plan to encourage your students to express themselves freely while still guiding them toward using standard writing conventions?

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Reflection 1: Stages of Writing Development

By -
      Last week, we conducted our own research on the  Stages of Writing Development  before the teacher introduced us to those outlined in ROG (2007). In my research, I came across the work of  Teale and Sulzby (1986) , which provided me with some insight into how children transition from scribbling and drawing to more conventional forms of writing. Then, our teacher later showed us the stages of ROG. It was interesting to compare what I had found with that of ROG's.       It was then, during my research, that I realized what I used to think of as “just scribbling” actually has real meaning. Teale and Sulzby describe how those early marks are a critical part of the preliterate stage, and ROG confirmed that children’s random symbols and drawings are not meaningless but are their first attempts at written communication. Before, I might have dismissed these as play, but now I see them as the very foundation of literacy.    ...
Read more

Reflective Post 1: The Value of Understanding the Stages of Writing

By -
Learning about the different stages of writing really opened my eyes to how students’ skills develop over time. The first three stages are mostly seen in the lower grades (K–3), while stages four to six appear as students move further along in school. For instance, emergent writers often begin with scribbles and drawings, while early writers use letters and invented spelling to form words and simple sentences. One of my classmates pointed out that writing can actually begin as early as Kindergarten. That insight reminded me that writing doesn’t have to be perfect at first; it’s a messy process of trial, error, and revisions before reaching a polished piece. I also realized that even the earliest attempts, like scri bbles or drawings, are meaningful and should be celebrated as the first steps in a child’s journey as a writer. As an educator, this makes me think about the importance of realistic expectations. I can’t expect a Grade 1 child to write like a Grade 6 student, b...
Read more

Guiding Young Writers: Insights from the 6+1 Traits

By -
Image
       What does it really mean to be a good writer? This week in LIT, exploring the 6+1 writing traits made me reflect on that question more deeply than ever. I have always thought about teaching writing as mostly showing students the rules, but examining traits such as ideas, organization, voice, word choice, sentence fluency, conventions, and presentation made me see writing in a new light. Each trait acts as a tool that helps students communicate their thoughts more clearly, confidently, and creatively. Writing is not just something students do. It is something they grow into, and each trait gives them ways to express themselves and develop their own voice.      One question I asked myself during the week was how I can help my students become better writers. This question was answered through our discussions and activities in class. Our lecturer asked us to get into groups based on our grade levels and explore the Language Arts standards of the OE...
Read more